Opposition to Penarth pods project make their point while council debates planning position. Boatyard boss says he will press on regardless of concern

By Neil Speight (Nub News) and Ted Peskett (LDRS) 12th Dec 2022

The company behind plans to install floating hotel pods in Penarth has insisted that their development is lawful after protesters turned out to block continued work.

Add it has been revealled that objectors to the scheme have been told the project will press ahead regardless of local concerns.

Meanwhile the Vale of Glamorgan Council revealed that it is investigating whether or not the floating hotel pods proposed for Penarth Marina require planning permission.

Two floating pods have already been set up on the marina and more are expected to be installed.

One of those at the forefront of opposition is local resident Nick Palit.

Nick Palit.

He told Nub News today (Monday, 12 December): "At a meeting this morning, Philip Lay - the Boatfolk director behind this scheme - today threatened us with legal action against us personally if we block his crane again.

"As a result of the protest he had agreed to meet with myself and another householder.

"However in the meeting - held at The Deck, he refused any compromise and said all ten pods would be Installed in front of our homes by mid January.

"We are still pursuing all legal avenues and VOG are investigating. Both MP Stephen Doughty and Vaughan Gething (Member of the Senedd for Cardiff South and Penarth) have said they're willing to help us if there's anything they can do.

"We're now waiting for the council enforcement investigation and legal department to reach their decisions.

"Once all ten are installed it will become apparent to everyone that this is completely out of keeping with its environment and is actually a de-facto hotel. However there is no planning permission for a hotel. A similar development in Milford Haven does have planning permission.

Last week residents who are opposed to the plans turned out to block further pods from being lifted into the water and they were successful after police declined a request to move them from the site.

Mr Palit, who lives at the Marina, said he first noticed the pods arriving about ten days ago.

He said: "They just appeared outside our house and I couldn't believe what I was seeing.

"Not only is it completely out of keeping with our environment, our view is completely obliterated, it goes against the whole nature of the place.

"We have got a lovely natural habitat for wild birds. There's kingfishers, there's coots, there's swans, all nesting on that grassy bank and that whole habitat will be ruined by the sighting of these 10 or 20 pods that are put there."

Last year, the council issued Boatfolk Marinas Limited with a certificate of lawfulness for the use of Penarth Marina for the floating pods.

The document confirming the council's decision states that the proposal for the floating pods, described as 'vessels' in the certificate of lawfulness, is "in line with the approved use of the site" and that a "material change of use" has not taken place.

Protesters at Penarth Marina block the installation of further floating hotel pods.

However, a number of residents argued that the floating pods are not technically vessels and that a change of use of the site has taken place.

Mr Palit added: "By anyone's definition, these are not vessels, these are not boats. They are floating portacabins and they are not even floating.

"They have been put on to a pontoon, then bolted to another pontoon and connected to mains sewage."

A spokesperson from the Vale of Glamorgan Council confirmed: "Following complaints about pods at Penarth Marina, the Council's Planning Team are investigating whether they require planning permission."

Gwyn Griffiths.

Gwynne Griffiths of the Marina and Haven Residents' Association, said: "For Boatfolk to try and put in more pods again while that process is going through is what we found was unacceptable."

Expressing his thoughts on the look of the containers, Mr Griffiths added: "Talking bluntly, they are just grey containers.

"Particularly with the way they are placed outside the houses, they are looking directly at the rear of a grey container."

Some of the residents who are opposed to the development also claim that there was no consultation with those who live next to the proposed location of the pods.

Nicola Roberts and Ann Turner expressed their opposition to the floating pods at Penarth Marina, saying they are not in keeping with the character of the area

Nicola Roberts, whose home looks out on to the back end of the pods, said she is "horrified" by them.

She said: "From our perspective, they look like public conveniences because we have got the back end of them.

"I just don't think they are suitable for this sort of environment anyway.

"The impact it is going to have on our lives is just dreadful. I have contemplated selling up."

Another resident of the marina, Ann Turner, said: "They are not vessels. They are just inappropriate for the Marina. It is going to spoil the whole ambience of it.

"The reason we are here today is because we feel that if we don't make a stand they will be here and once they are in, they are in."

A spokesperson for Boatfolk said: "We can confirm that we have pursued all the appropriate channels for berthing these unique vessels within Penarth Marina, including significant engagement with the Council, and we are confident that they are lawful.

"The floating rooms are non-permanent structures that are capable of being navigated out of the marina and therefore fulfil the definition of a vessel for planning purposes.

"We are also confident that they will have no additional impact on the local environment and refute any claims that the addition of the rooms will pose a threat to local wildlife."

     

New penarth Jobs Section Launched!!
Vacancies updated hourly!!
Click here: penarth jobs

Share:


Sign-Up for our FREE Newsletter

We want to provide penarth with more and more clickbait-free local news.
To do that, we need a loyal newsletter following.
Help us survive and sign up to our FREE weekly newsletter.

Already subscribed? Thank you. Just press X or click here.
We won't pass your details on to anyone else.
By clicking the Subscribe button you agree to our Privacy Policy.